Another 42+ Sarah Levy Emily Hampshire Sarah Levy Annie Murphy. Annie murphy was offered the role of spoiled socialite alexis rose after actress abby elliott, who had portrayed the character in the presentation. First posted on jan 16, 2019 dan levy, annie murphy, sarah levy and emily hampshire sit down to talk about the making of season 5, episode 2, love letters. Cast roundtable | eugene, catherine, dan, annie, chris and jenn.